Outrageous DPW ticketing/registration policy: A case study
Tuesday, 22 April 2008
- Sonya Jongsma Knauss
Hello Ald. Coggs, Pres. Hines and Mayor Barrett,I'm writing this letter in hopes that it will help me cool down enough to go back to sleep. And to find out whether what just happened to my family is still actually policy by the city that needs to be changed or was a miscarriage of justice. I'm inclined to think that it was probably both.
Here's the story:
I was awakened 15 min ago (about 3:30 AM) by a friendly neighbor leaning on the doorbell repeatedly. My car was getting towed...
We ran out to talk to the tow truck driver immediately. He was pretty stoic about it and ignored my pleas for him to take a look at my proof of registration, which had been renewed and was good through August 08. He had his towing slip, and apparently the faceless bureaucracy that is the smooth functioning machine of Milwaukee DPW can't stop to listen to reason. He was going to tow it.
"The parking checker is right up there," he told me helpfully, pointing half a block up. "She wrote the tow slip."
I ran in my pajamas to where Officer Casey (payroll No. 008875) was writing out another ticket. I had mine in my hand as I came up to her.
I asked her what was going on.
"You have an 07 registration on your plate," she said, dismissing my concern.
"I know," I told her. "The 08 sticker fell off a couple times when I tried to put it on, and I haven't been able to get it to stick. I keep it in the car. I can get it for you right now and show it to you."
She wasn't interested. Besides, she already know my registration was good and was renewed even though the $50 ticket in my hand told me that it was for "unregistered/improperly registered vehicle."
"I did see that you renewed it in the computer," she told me. I was incredulous.
I appealed to her again, asking her why in the world she was having my car TOWED for an infraction that she knew wasn't even a true violation. I was pretty upset to come out and find my car prepped for hauling away at 3:15 a.m.
"Why are you towing it?" I asked her again.
I'm not sure if this is an exact quote, but this is what her answer boiled down to: "Because I CAN!"
She refused to ask the tow truck driver to put the car back where it was. She refused to rescind the ticket. She refused to consider the fact that nothing at all was wrong with my car (there were not even any outstanding parking tickets on it) other than the fact that a little sticker had fallen off my license plate.
Even with me there, pleading with her not to tow the car because of the cost, the hassle and trouble for our family of six, which needs two cars to take care of its needs most days, she was adamant.
Because I can, she said. I watched my car roll down the street on the back of the big tow truck and gave up to come back inside. But I can't sleep.
Why was this woman unable and unwilling to listen to my completely reasonable argument that it was hugely unjust to tow a car that she KNEW had a renewed registration??
I'd like to submit to you that her attitude, and that policy, is a huge problem.
Now I understand how some of my neighbors to the south in Brewers Hill felt this summer when they got repeatedly slapped for $50 fines for improper registration after their registration stickers were stolen. A friend of mine said, "I feel like the DPW is trying to drive me out of the city."
If the city is able to tell that a person has renewed their registration, why in the world still tow a car? Is that standard policy? Even if it's not, why is it allowable?
Additionally, I was under the impression, based on communication with Sam McGovern Rowen from Ald. D'Amato's office last year, that the punitive DPW policy that allowed a $50 ticket for failure to display registration had been modified so that parking checkers would only give $15 fines if they ran a plate check and found that the car had be registered but simply didn't have the sticker on the plate.
Incidents like these feel like such an incredible slap in the face to people who want to be proud of the city they live in and who want to work hard for it to thrive.
I am very upset. And I am facing the ridiculous situation of a $50 ticket, probably $80 or more to get my car back from the city tow lot, and the inability to take my family where they need to go in the morning without a whole lot of trouble.
All because I have to PAY the city to park in the street in front of my own house, and because a parking checker thought it would be more fun to play bad cop with me than give a $15 ticket.
Please let me know what my recourse in this issue is.
Readers: if you take issue with the City knowingly towing registered vehicles for non-registration, please contact your alderman and the Department of Public Works' Administration Services Parking Division to request a change in policy: Janice Buechner (286-8345) and Debra Washington (286-8361).
Set as favorite
Bookmark
Email this
Trackback(0)
TrackBack URI for this entryComments (7)
Subscribe to this comment's feedShow/hide comments
That\'s outrageous
If anybody who needs to check registration has a gizmo that quickly confirms registration, then why is there any fine for not having the sticker? At best, there should be a small fine (the $15) to provide incentive to put the stickers on for efficiency purposes. Towing a registered vehicle is absurd. If the city is looking for money, increase the fines for cars that are unregistered. Crack down on the people who didn't make an attempt to follow the rules.
I hope there's hell to pay. Good luck!
I hope there's hell to pay. Good luck!
...
I live in a townhouse with four parking stalls. Every year all of our cars have had our lic. plates chopped up for the stickers. I have purposely left the sticker of my plate off because It will cost be a replacement fee to put another sticker on. I believe that the police department/DPW needs to update their policy ASAP. Theft of these stickers hurts law abiding citizens, and then the government penalizes us a second time. I personally have a 06 sticker on my plate (living dangerously) and have my 08 in my glove box. I have been lucky, but I will now put my 08 on and tempt fate. You are awesome to have shared this story and I hope the City gets with the program and stops parking harrassment.
Elogical1
Elogical1
please make some calls
So far no responses from various city official on this today. (We got an early start at 4am.)
Please contribute to the cause of putting pressure on the bureaucracy to make life more livable in the city!
At the minimum, it costs quite some time, travel, and nearly $200 to deal with a situation like this--more than what it has generally cost to deal with actual criminal-conducted auto larceny and break-ins. This can really screw a person badly if they have only one car, tenuous/inflexible employers, and little disposable income.
Please contribute to the cause of putting pressure on the bureaucracy to make life more livable in the city!
At the minimum, it costs quite some time, travel, and nearly $200 to deal with a situation like this--more than what it has generally cost to deal with actual criminal-conducted auto larceny and break-ins. This can really screw a person badly if they have only one car, tenuous/inflexible employers, and little disposable income.
STICKER PROTECTION
The stickers on all my vehicles have been finely sliced with a razor blade to make it unattractive to steal them. This was suggested by Officer Robakowski. It is also illegal to have your plates in the window as opposed to on your car. Generally you will be fined for this only if you get stopped for other violations. Kind of like the seat belt law. Hope this helps.
to hell with stickers
Dan, the razor blade method doesn't work. At worst it will increase the chance of your sticker gcoming off over time as moisure gets under it. At best it will result in part of your sticker being torn away by a thief, which is probably enough to get you a ticket--if not a towing. It does nothing for stickers that don't stick all year in the first place. Clearing away previous year stickers and degreasing the surface before adding a new decal (who does that?) still doesn't guarantee your sticker will be there all year.
Many thieves just clip the whole corner off your plate, presumably so they can work the sticker off carefully somewhere else. Then you need to buy a new plate! DPW still tickets and tows plates that have clearly been clipped. The frames the police will sell you for your plate as an anti-clipping device do not work either. Last year a friend had her stickers clipped repeatedly, she installed the anti-clipping frame, and she got clipped again. If I recall correctly, there was also some unnecessary towing involved for her too.
These decals should simply be eliminated and replaced by windshield stickers you put on the INSIDE of your car, just like the overnight parking permit.
And when it comes to towing, this needs to be done without violation or such egregious violation of due process rights, especially by unsworn non-law enforcement officers. Evidently state and local laws have codified unconstitutional powers allowing the city to deprive you of property and extort cash from you without any kind of hearing. This is bullshit.
At least if you lose a sticker, you can get another for free by phone or email. From the DMV:
You can obtain duplicate or replacement license plate sticker(s) by sending an e-mail message to the Bureau of Vehicle Services at: bur-veh-services.dmv@dot.state.wi.us. Include the following information:
* The vehicle year, make and identification number (VIN #)
* The license plate number and type of sticker needed
* Your full name, including your middle initial, (if any)
* Your complete mailing address, including city, state and zip code
* An e-mail address and/or telephone number, including area code, where you can be reached between the hours of 7:30 a.m. and 4:30 p.m., Monday through Friday, in case we need to contact you for additional information.
To apply by telephone call [608] 266-1466, 24 hours every day including holidays, to leave a recorded message. You will be asked for your license plate number and the type of sticker needed.
The sticker requested will be mailed to you the next business day.
Many thieves just clip the whole corner off your plate, presumably so they can work the sticker off carefully somewhere else. Then you need to buy a new plate! DPW still tickets and tows plates that have clearly been clipped. The frames the police will sell you for your plate as an anti-clipping device do not work either. Last year a friend had her stickers clipped repeatedly, she installed the anti-clipping frame, and she got clipped again. If I recall correctly, there was also some unnecessary towing involved for her too.
These decals should simply be eliminated and replaced by windshield stickers you put on the INSIDE of your car, just like the overnight parking permit.
And when it comes to towing, this needs to be done without violation or such egregious violation of due process rights, especially by unsworn non-law enforcement officers. Evidently state and local laws have codified unconstitutional powers allowing the city to deprive you of property and extort cash from you without any kind of hearing. This is bullshit.
At least if you lose a sticker, you can get another for free by phone or email. From the DMV:
You can obtain duplicate or replacement license plate sticker(s) by sending an e-mail message to the Bureau of Vehicle Services at: bur-veh-services.dmv@dot.state.wi.us. Include the following information:
* The vehicle year, make and identification number (VIN #)
* The license plate number and type of sticker needed
* Your full name, including your middle initial, (if any)
* Your complete mailing address, including city, state and zip code
* An e-mail address and/or telephone number, including area code, where you can be reached between the hours of 7:30 a.m. and 4:30 p.m., Monday through Friday, in case we need to contact you for additional information.
To apply by telephone call [608] 266-1466, 24 hours every day including holidays, to leave a recorded message. You will be asked for your license plate number and the type of sticker needed.
The sticker requested will be mailed to you the next business day.
...
I've heard that painting clear nail polish over the sticker makes it very difficult to peal off. I don't know if I'd want my plates in the window or a sticker on the windshield, then thieves would just have another reason to break into my car. In any case, I hope your letter makes something happen, Sonja. I feel for your family- if our van was gone we'd be totally screwed.



























